Better late than never: Our thoughts on last week:
Without making too big a fuss over the spending cuts released by the House today, a few quick points.
First, the cuts are brutal and deep, and they are disproportionately brutal and deep for the poorest among us. It costs relatively little to fund nutrition assistance to the needy, but it does enormous good.
But the cuts are hardest on some of the services we need the most. Education, Labor, and HHS: 7.3%. Transportation: 15%. Energy Development: 11.5%. It's a dystopian future the House imagines for us. Reduced investment in education and infrastructure, increased reliance on fossil fuels, kneecapped environmental protections, and an altogether heavier burden of poverty.
Secondly, let no one argue that they don't know the priorities of the Republican House. This is as much a manifesto as a budget authority. Even as they propose to take a hammer to social programs and regulatory authorities, they find room to increase defense spending by 3%. This is a fundamental debate on what the government should be involved in. The House's opinion? Not in helping the poor. Not in educating our children or building our highways. Not in regulating our banks.
Lastly, and most importantly, all of this highlights the uselessness of a non-defense discretionary spending cut. That type of spending is 15% of the federal budget - less, if you discount the Veterans Administration. And from that 15% comes almost everything we identify as government. The FBI. The Department of Education. Transportation grants. Nutrition assistance. Farm subsidies, if that's your thing. And if we cut every single one of these departments in entirety, we'll still be left with a government 85% as large as it is today.
15%? Christ. The DoD will make up that difference in a decade.
In return for that, we'll get a country that, with a degrading infrastructure and handicapped education system, is less able to meet the challenges of the next century. Something that is likely to make our budget problem worse, not better. It's a wonderful deal.
Maybe all of this would be understandable if taxes weren't near the lowest point they've been in history. But they are. Maybe if investors were demanding massive interest rates in return for purchasing government debt. They aren't. Maybe if the actions of the Fed were sparking widespread core inflation and crowding out business investment. But they haven't. This isn't an act of necessity. It's a choice. And it's a choice that speaks volumes of the eagerness and the ethics of the people who make it.
